Are you ready to expand your beauty business but not sure how to structure the compensation model? Should you hire a team of employees, booth-rent, or bring on independent contractors?
We need to consider how different compensation models affect your business plan and profit margins. It’s also important to know what you want to create.
There isn’t really a one-size-fits-all answer. When I work with my VIP clients who are at this crossroad of expanding their business, the first question I ask is, “What do you want?”
I know, that might sound like the easiest question on the planet but you’d be surprised to hear that most spa business owners don’t really know. It’s important to get clear on this because we all want different things. What you want may not come close to what I want.
Some owners believe the next step in business is bringing on new people. Mostly because this is what you’re “supposed to do.” Other spa owners simply follow what others are doing – even if it’s illegal.
So, there is some confusion around business expansion and how to handle compensation when you want to bring on new people.
In an effort to raise the bar in the beauty industry, we should become more informed so we can choose the right compensation model for our business.
Common Compensation Models In the Beauty Industry
Here’s a breakdown of the most common ways beauty business owners can expand their business and structure compensation. Understanding how each model works can help you make an informed decision:
Hiring Employees For Your Beauty Business
An employee is someone who’s hired for a wage, salary, fee, or payment to perform work for an employer.
When you hire an employee for your business, you have more control over behaviors during working hours, such as the performance of services, how one carries out operational procedures or dress code, to name a few.Remember that anyone who is in your business sphere is a reflection of you and your brand. Click To Tweet
Hiring the right employees gives you much better control over how your clients perceive and experience your brand when they interact with anyone on your team.
Booth-Rent In Your Beauty Business
At first glance, the booth-renting model can be appealing. You can fill all your treatment rooms, charge a monthly fee for each, and have your rent covered. Easy peasy, right?
Sounds easy until one of your renters does something that isn’t in alignment with the way you do business.
You don’t have control over the booth renters because they’re independent operators.
Booth renters can dress and behave however they want. They can work whatever hours they like and sell their choice in retail products. You’ll end up with a bunch of micro business owners running around doing things their own way.
Most of the time there’s no cohesiveness or synergy among renters so clients who come to your spa won’t get an experience that’s unique to your brand.
The way you want to run your spa isn’t your renters’ priority – things could work out okay or they could become a nightmare.
Independent Contractors In Your Beauty Business
Many spa owners bring in 1099 contractors but treat them like employees. Or expect these contractors to behave like employees.
Some owners offer high commission pay structures which are not sustainable and can have dangerous financial implications.
Bringing in independent contractors can mean fewer responsibilities, such as health insurance and payroll taxes. However, most commission only based pay structures are illegal. I don’t want you to get into trouble.
Determine The Best Way To Expand Your Business
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to how you structure your business and compensation model. It depends on what it is you wish to create.
When I owned my spa, I hired employees who were aligned with our mission, vision, and core values..
The new hire went through a lengthy onboarding process to integrate them into the culture which helped set them up for success. New hires were given an employee handbook and extensive training operationally and hands-on.Stick to your plan for expansion - don't copy others plans. Click To Tweet
The only time I brought in an independent contractor was for a service that wasn’t one of our core offerings.
This contractor had her own way of doing things but it was in alignment with the brand image I built. I simply provided her with space and considered it as a value-add service for our guests.
I recommend only bringing in independent contractors if they have different services from what you currently offer at your spa. Even then, make sure you select someone who can present an image that’s in alignment with you and your brand.
Compensation Trends And Models In the Beauty Business
Here are some of my observations regarding compensation trends and models. It’s been an interesting circle in the last three decades
Beauty Business Hiring Trends
In my opinion, the most recent trend started when the industry somewhat “fell apart” back in 2008. The recession had fifty plus salons and spas closing daily.
Many licensed professionals wanted to have their own businesses and the “solopreneur boom” in the beauty industry was born.
However, many realized soon enough how hard it was to work behind the chair and run a business simultaneously.
Now, the tide has turned. I’m coaching many clients who are expanding from solo to building a team… and we’re coming full circle.
Many solo owners have a solid vision and want to build a team of leaders.
More estheticians who went solo are now joining other spa businesses as employees, which allows them to focus on their expertise rather than trying to run a business.
The truth is, not everyone is meant to own a business… it’s a totally different animal.
I know, many solo estheticians and hair stylists would say, “No way! I’d never work for anyone again!” But what if it was the right owner? What if you loved coming to work and were treated with respect and getting paid your worth?
If you’re an employer, it’s important to create the appropriate environment to attract the right talent. If you’re an employee, look for a business that will allow you to thrive while knowing you’ll need to put in the effort to grow your book of clientele.
Beauty Business Compensation Trend
I believe that the days of high commission structures are over. High commission pay-outs are not sustainable for the business which forces many to close their doors.
I like to see a compensation formula that’s a mix of an hourly rate plus performance-based bonus.
In addition, don’t forget to figure in gratuities. Tips are a big part of a spa employee’s earnings, and therefore should be counted as part of the income.
My mission is to help spa owners build teams and expand their business seamlessly. If you’re ready to expand your beauty business and want to learn from someone who has “been there done that,” fill out the Elite VIP Coaching Application and I will be in touch.
Note: I am not employment attorney. If you have questions regarding your employment status, I suggest you speak to an attorney or contact the Department of Labor in your state.